10 Responses

  1. Footballgambler
    February 6, 2010 at 8:11 pm | | Reply


    Not a Villa fan but on the basis of the last decade though, it must surely be Gareth Barry, the only reason Villa fans would probably overlook him is because of the circumstances in which he left.

    I do believe that Martin O’Neill misses Martin Laursen more than Barry though, in signing Richard Dunne he has attempted to replace him. He may well have plugged the hole at the back left by Laursen, but I don’t think he is ever going to replace the goals he scored.

    Wheres Ian Taylor?

    And by the way, how the hell has ex Villa manager David O’Leary managed to get a job summarizing on the Spanish football on Sky?

    You watch a beautiful performance from Barcelona and then have to listen to him analyse it.

    What are his credentials on Spanish football? I don’t recall him ever playing or managing there? Or managing anywhere (properly) for that matter.

  2. patrick
    patrick
    February 6, 2010 at 10:12 pm | | Reply


    where is Nigel Rio Coker or Marlon Harewood. clearly the best players ever bought for 12 million pounds.

    1. trust me
      trust me
      February 8, 2010 at 3:50 am | | Reply


      Davies 10m

  3. patrick
    patrick
    February 6, 2010 at 10:17 pm | | Reply


    better question is… who would care? its not like Villa won anything. I’m West Ham and listing the team of the last decade would be pointless. why not the best Wigan 11 ever. or best knuckle draggers ever at Bolton. What would be a winner would be, most ethically challenged footballers in the last decade!

  4. DM
    DM
    February 7, 2010 at 7:44 am | | Reply


    Barry easily. I think these polls should never be conducted by a clubs supporters but their opposition fans. Barry if playing yesterday would have given some composure to a team that looked more similar to Hull than a team with a league cup final and aiming for 4th. I couldn’t pay to watch that every week, and MON now looks stupid because on that showing for once most Spurs fans agree with Wenger about Villa being a bit drab.

  5. Dave
    Dave
    February 8, 2010 at 8:17 am | | Reply


    patrick- Reo Coker and Harewood cost £12 million? Do some research, get a calculator and then come back with your head hanging in shame. And I care by the way, and so do the 40, 000 people who attend home matches. And so do ESPN who seem to have figured that Villa get the biggest viewing figures outside the so-called top four. If all you care about is winning then Lord knows why you are a West Ham fan in the first place. Not everyone thinks that a trophy is the only thing that matters in football. If you ever attended any matches you would know that.

    And to DM, concluding that a team which beat Liverpool at Anfield 3-1 and Man United at Old Trafford are dull simply because they had a tense, tactical match against two arrogant teams from the South (whose deluded fans think they are watching the equivelant of Brazil 1970 every week) shows how much you know about football as well. Who hasn’t seen Chelsea, Arsenal, Man U, Liverpool, Spurs and Everton play that way?

    1. patrick
      patrick
      February 8, 2010 at 9:36 am | | Reply


      yes I freely admit, that 12m was off the top of my head. So I did research it. Reo Coker 8.5m, Harewood 4m so I was wrong. It was 12.5 million pounds.

      West Ham has great support as well, but my point is you are hardly listing world beaters there. Maybe I should do a list of West Ham players that got away. and trust me I know its NOT about silverware. Its about getting behind your club no matter. Like I will next season when we are playing in the fizzy pop.

  6. This One Guy In Detroit
    This One Guy In Detroit
    February 8, 2010 at 9:10 am | | Reply


    “Do you agree with Martin Laursen as number one? Would you have Gareth Barry in the list given his exit from the club and does Paul Merson deserve to be on the list at all? Let us know by leaving a comment below.”

    Have I stumbled onto Soccer By Ives?! :-)

  7. M. Sparks
    M. Sparks
    February 8, 2010 at 11:10 am | | Reply


    Brad Friedel should be on the list. In the last few years as Villa have pushed for a top 6 spot he has kept them in games. I would say 10 points a year can be attributed to Friedel’s play alone. A good example is this years game at Old Trafford if not for Friedel that game is 4 to 1. Performances like that are why I think he should be included.

  8. Scott B.
    Scott B.
    March 21, 2010 at 9:17 am | | Reply


    Cheers for the article David. I agree with all five on the list but maybe Gareth Barry would top it for me.

Leave a Reply